62.5 F
New York
Sunday, September 24, 2023
HomeArchiveISP’s: Do They Or Don’t They Have To Police Pirate Sites?

ISP’s: Do They Or Don’t They Have To Police Pirate Sites?


Related stories

Apple Vision Pro: The Next Big Flop In Apple’s Hall Of Shame?

Apple is one of the greatest companies on earth. They produce products that are unequalled in consumer technology. But like any company, they release products that are flops in the marketplace. Apple, unlike a lot of other companies, knows how to bury their stiffs like they never existed.

Station Narva 2023: Lost In Transition

The Music Void attended the sixth edition of Station...

Why You Should Invest In AI Over The Metaverse

In today's rapidly advancing technological landscape, businesses are constantly seeking ways to gain a competitive edge. Among the emerging options, artificial intelligence (AI) and the metaverse have garnered significant attention. However, when it comes to investing their resources, businesses should prioritize AI over the metaverse.

Music Streaming Industry: A Saturation Showdown Is On The Horizon

The music streaming industry has witnessed remarkable growth over the past decade, with streaming services becoming the primary mode of music consumption for millions worldwide. However, with rapid expansion come concerns of potential market saturation and challenges related to subscription models.

Don’t Trust Your Spotify Algorithm. Trust Your Heart.

Researchers in sunny California have turned the age-old question of "Can machines predict hit songs?" into a musical rollercoaster ride. Forget about musical fortune tellers; these scientists at Claremont Graduate University have put AI to the test, trying to predict the next chart-topping hit with the help of your heart rate.

It’s been an interesting past few weeks, where in the UK we have the high court rule that BT must remove all links to torrent sight Newzbin2. Then just last week the European Court Of Justice ruled that ISP’s cannot spy on their customer’s usage. At the same time France’s President Nicolas Sarkozy announced that they want to Tax ISPs to fund music, as well as add streaming to their three strikes law. And finally to top it all of Australian ISPs came out yesterday and announced ISP’s volunteered to police piracy.

Talk about contradictions, yet depending on the country rights owners have a clear mandate to ensure ISP’s block offending sites and in others they do not. So where do rights holders in the UK and France stand in relation to the previously announced European ruling? If anything these counter rulings have just caused more confusion and in the end ensure the water is even muddier when it comes to content owners rights in respect of privacy.

Its seems that whilst Brussels’ has made it clear that ISP’s cannot track their customers usage, than the knock on effect of this is that content owners would now have no redress when it comes to pursuing offenders. Content owners cannot track offender’s illegal behaviour without the help of ISP’s whom refuse to prevent their users from partaking in illegal activity. 

In the UK we have BT and the belligerent twats at Carphone Warehouse refusing to budge. As previously stated numerous times on TMV if you charge people to use your Gateway to access the internet than you have both a legal and moral obligation to prevent illegal activity occurring on via your network. It is as black and white as that folks. 

If ISP’s continue to be as blind to the fact that it is important for both our culture and society in general that illegal activity is monitored on the Internet, than perhaps the French solution of a tax on ISPs to fund music is the way forward?

Or there is a middle road and it seems ISP’s in Australia are leading the way on this particular point.  The Australia Telco industry body the communications alliance proposed that they will send first time offenders an ‘education notice’ if a customer is suspected of pirating a movie. In the proposal ISPs note that if the offender persists they will be sent three warning notices in a twelve-month period and only then would they hand over the offenders details to copyright holders. 

Whilst a start in terms of ISP’s coming to the table TMV do believe that giving an offender 12 months to continue to pirate content is not viable. Especially considering that most consumers move to a new broadband provider once ever year or two. Apparently the French three strikes figure show that “only 0.1 percent of users who receive a first notice will continue their activities and receive a third notice” according to John Stanton the CEO of the Communications Alliance. 

That aforementioned is an astonishing figure, and in TMV’s view should perhaps encourage both content owners and ISP’s to come together and agree a three strikes style approach, as the French statistics seem to point to the effectiveness of such an approach. So ISP’s lets stop being so pro-piracy and instead engage and implement a proven solution.


  • Jakomi Mathews

    Jakomi was the original founder of The Music Void in 2007. His first startup was www.akamedia.net. Where back in 2001 we were able to track audio and audio visual broadcasts. We targeted the music industry performing rights societies as customer but ironically it was the radio broadcast who used our service to prove ads were broadcast to their advertising clients - yet the ironically PRO's started using the service from 2015 when they were dragged kicking and screaming into the 2nd decade of the 21st century. He has deep insights into the inner workings of the music business and digital music generally from working with RWD Magazine and then Rock Sound in the UK during the early 2000's. He was then involved in building some of the first artist mobile apps both before and just after the release of the first iPhone. He also worked with Muse's management for a short time and has managed an assortment of artists from Australia and the UK. He now has a new startup called goto.health which is focused on disrupting the healthcare booking sector on a global basis.


- Never miss a story with notifications

- Gain full access to our premium content

- Browse free from up to 5 devices at once

Latest stories



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here